Global, Opinion

Constant flux

24.06.2021, International cooperation

The only constant in life, as Heraclitus taught us, is change. Yet, it was almost 13 years ago now that I took up my first position at Alliance Sud. For family reasons, the time has now come to say farewell.

Constant flux

© Daniel Rihs / Alliance Sud

In 2008 when I assumed responsibility for area of «tax policy» at Alliance Sud, Finance Minister Hans-Rudolf Merz still believed that Switzerland’s banking secrecy was as immovable as the Gotthard Massif. Nothing stood in the way of tax evaders and corrupt dictators in developing countries who wanted to conceal their fortunes in Switzerland. Then came the global financial and economic crisis, which sounded the death knell for many of the Millennium Development Goals that should have been attained by 2015; on the other hand, however, it gave fresh momentum to the fight against tax evasion.

Suddenly, even the powerful industrial countries were keen to crack down on tax offenders. They urgently needed more government revenues to pay for their multi-billion bailout packages for banks. For its part, however, Alliance Sud had to fight on for years until Switzerland finally extended automatic information exchange in tax matters to developing countries. It is still campaigning against the deplorable incentives available to multinational corporations to shift their profits from poor countries to Switzerland, largely untaxed.

When in 2015 I succeeded Peter Niggli as Director of Alliance Sud, the Sustainable Development Goals were just taking the place of the Millennium Development Goals. Through the 2030 Agenda the rich industrial countries committed to a course of action geared not merely towards short-term national interests but to the long-term well-being of humanity and the planet. This makes it all the more surprising today to witness the degree of exasperation with which some Federal Councillors and Parliamentarians greet NGOs that get involved in Swiss policy in order to promote respect for human rights and the protection of the environment.

Then, as now, Alliance Sud was a political irritant. We should not be impressed by the latest tit-for-tat responses to civil society for taking an active interest in development policy. Now more than ever, socially equitable and environmentally sustainable world development calls for a Switzerland that aligns all policies coherently with this goal – from foreign to economic policy, and including climate policy. The Alliance Sud team, member organisations and allies will continue to advocate for this cause in the future, with dedication, indefatigable commitment and the power of the right arguments. I take this opportunity to thank them from the bottom of my heart for the wonderful cooperation we have had.

Global Logo

global

The Alliance Sud magazine analyses and comments on Switzerland's foreign and development policies. "global" is published four times a year (in german and french) and can be subscribed to free of charge.

Development cooperation

Development cooperation

Development cooperation on a partnership basis contributes effectively to sustainable development and peace in the world. This will first require the "localising" and "decolonising" of traditional "development aid". Alliance Sud champions development cooperation that is geared towards partner country priorities and strengthens civil society organisations. 

What it is about >

What it is about

There are ever more insistent calls, chiefly from civil society in the Global South, for development cooperation and humanitarian aid to be fully decolonised, geared towards the priorities of partner countries, and for cooperation to take place on a partnership basis.

It will need unrelenting efforts to break down existing patterns of funding, knowledge generation and cooperation, to share decision-making power, and to make room for non-Western patterns of thought and action. Lastly, racist images, jargons and behaviours need to be recognised and eliminated. Through its work and communication, Alliance Sud works towards overcoming unequal power relations and practices.

Press release

Andreas Missbach becomes new Director of Alliance Sud

29.09.2021, International cooperation

The Board of Alliance Sud has elected Andreas Missbach as the new Director. He takes over from Mark Herkenrath, who left Alliance Sud at the end of July. Andreas Missbach will take office on 1 January 2022.

Andreas Missbach becomes new Director of Alliance Sud

Andreas Missbach

"We are delighted to have attracted a distinguished figure to assume the challenging mission," says Bernd Nilles, Chairman of Alliance Sud and Director of Swiss Catholic Lenten Fund. “Andreas Missbach is the ideal incumbent. His wide-ranging experience, extensive network and strategic mind-set will be a boost to Alliance Sud in its commitment to equitable North-South relations and a Switzerland that is guided by solidarity. Andreas Missbach will be a competent contact person for politicians and the Administration."

Andreas Missbach (born in 1966) is a historian, he has written a dissertation on United Nations climate policy, and from 2001 to 2021 served the Berne Declaration/Public Eye in various fields, most recently as a Joint Managing Director and Head of the Department for Commodities, Trade & Finance.

"I am delighted to work with Alliance Sud for global justice and to strengthen the voice of the global South and of development organizations in Swiss politics," says Andreas Missbach. This is more necessary than ever: whether climate crisis or Corona crisis, it is the poorest population groups who are hit the hardest."

Alliance Sud is the development policy alliance of the following Swiss development organizations: Swissaid, Swiss Catholic Lenten Fund, Bread for All, Helvetas, Caritas and HEKS/EPER. It is also supported by the following partner organizations: Solidar Suisse, Terre des Hommes Switzerland and the Swiss Red Cross. For 50 years now Alliance Sud has championed the causes of a more just world and a Switzerland that shows solidarity.

Further information:
Bernd Nilles, Chairman of Alliance Sud and Director of Swiss Catholic Lenten Fund

Global, Opinion

Reimagining Africa

01.10.2021, International cooperation

The world is jaded by the multiple planetary emergencies upon us. These emergencies are compounded by the widespread failure of leadership at both the public and private sector levels.

Reimagining Africa

Co-President of the Club of Rome and Co-Founder of Reimagine SA.
© Mamphela Ramphele

Scientific knowledge is proving inadequate to the task of getting humanity to reimagine new ways of being human.  Reimagination requires going deep into oneself. Such reimagination demands of us to be prepared to unlearn our extractive value systems and learn anew from nature that we are part of an interconnected and interdepended web of life. As indigenous cultures across the world teach us – we have to become indigenous again and function within the rhythm of nature’s wisdom.  Becoming indigenous again would enable humanity to emerge from these emergencies with a new human civilization – one in harmony with nature.

Young people all over the world are slowly but surely rising to the challenge of leadership in the face of the failures of their parents and leaders.  Global movements such as Fridays for the Future, Extinction Rebellion, Rainbow Warriors, and Avaaz have taken it upon themselves to shape the future they desperately wish to see emerge.

Young people in Africa are also rising to the opportunities of embracing the wisdom of their ancestors.  Africa’s wisdom is that it is a land of abundance – there is enough for all if we share equitably. The value system of Ubuntu enables all to share in the prosperity generated through collaborative work.  There are no free riders in Ubuntu.

A significant proportion of the more than 600 million 15-49 year old Africans, are building innovative solutions to address the multiple challenges they face across a multiplicity of contexts.  They are turning scarcity of provision of old technologies in telecommunications and financial services, into opportunities to create abundance.  Cell phones and online financial services are leveraging the estimated annual flows of remittances (estimated at 44bn USD) to establish cheaper and more reliable connectedness between the diaspora and the home base.

Africa is also slowly dismantling the colonial education models that have held her youthful population hostage to education systems that alienate them from their rich cultural heritage. Colonial education models have mentally enslaved Africans for generations, making many to continue to believe in white supremacy and black inferiority.  It is this mental slavery that continues to undermine Africa’s ability to leverage its abundance to generate shared prosperity.

We are witnessing the creation of new education models such as the seventeen year old Leap Math and Science Schools in South Africa, that are helping young people to free themselves from this mental slavery and to embrace the wisdom of Ubuntu.  The healing impact of interconnectedness and interdependence results in self-confidence and restored dignity and self-respect.  The outcomes are spectacular in the poorest most broken slum areas of South Africa from which they come.  Leap graduates become leaders in their broken communities as teachers, engineers, civil society, political actors and many other professionals.  These outcomes belie the poverty the world sees in Africa.  Young people see abundance, and are the abundance of Africa.   

Africa as the largest continent (landmass equal to Europe, China and USA combined) with the largest resource base (60% arable land; 90% of mineral deposits, sun and rain in abundance; and the most youthful population of 1,4bn) needs to find a new development model.  Such a model has to be framed within the Ubuntu philosophy to leverage this rich resource base through collective action that unleashes the talents and creativity of its youthful population.

The world stands to gain from an Africa pursuing a more sustainable regenerative socio-economic development model.  Such an Africa would be able to share its abundance in a more equitable way.  Africa’s youthful population, freed from mental slavery and affirmed as innovative energetic global citizens, would provide the critical skills and creativity that the rest of the aging global community would need. The world needs to co-invest with Africa in an accelerated regenerative socio-economic development that leverages Africa’s land mass for food security. Drawing on Africa’s indigenous knowledge of organic agriculture and her rich marine food systems would ensure secure healthy food for all.

Africa’s minerals that are fuelling the world economy, including the newfound rare earths essential for electronics, need to be mined in a sustainable way.  Extractive mining practices are not only damaging the African landscapes, but undermining the wellbeing of her people. Sustainability of the flow of the benefits of mineral wealth for the entire global community requires radical transformation  from extractive approaches to regenerative ones.

The world need to seize the COVID pandemic and climate change existential crises as opportunities to learn anew how to work together as a global community.  This would ensure that we shift from degenerative approaches to regenerative ones that promote sustainable wellbeing for all.  This entails changing excessive consumption patterns to wiser choices to enable us stay within planetary boundaries. It also entails that we embrace nature’s wisdom that there can be no Me without We. Humanity is inextricably interconnected and interdependent.

My reimagined Africa in 50 years’ time is that of a continent that has reclaimed her heritage as the cradle of humanity and of the first human civilization, modelling nature’s intelligence to ensure that everyone contributes their best to the wellbeing of all in the entire ecosystem. Africa would then offer the world a model of how to learn anew to become fully human.

Global Logo

global

The Alliance Sud magazine analyses and comments on Switzerland's foreign and development policies. "global" is published four times a year (in german and french) and can be subscribed to free of charge.

Opinion

Fifty years of advocacy for solidarity

05.10.2021, International cooperation

Alliance Sud has been working for a Switzerland of solidarity for 50 years. Our President Bernd Nilles looks back - and into the future.

Fifty years of advocacy for solidarity

Bernd Nilles, President of Alliance Sud and Director of Swiss Catholic Lenten Fund
© Fastenopfer

Fifty years of Alliance Sud, 60 years of Swiss Development Cooperation (SDC), 60 years of Swiss Catholic Lenten Fund, 75 years of HEKS/EPER – a few decades ago the mood was overwhelmingly upbeat regarding global responsibility. Is there cause for celebration today, or perhaps not, considering the number of unsolved problems in the world? We are constantly facing new challenges and crises – including the climate crisis and the considerable time pressure it entails.

When in August 1971 – shortly after the introduction of women's suffrage – our founding fathers set up the Swiss Coalition Swissaid/Swiss Catholic Lenten Fund/Bread for Brethren/Helvetas, they presumably had no idea that the journey was to last five decades and beyond. The initial focus was on informing the Swiss public about the situation in developing countries and about global interconnections; development policy was only added later, in the 1980s. The early realisation that long-term transformation would necessitate changes in the North and South was a far-sighted one, and the successful unification of Swiss aid agencies with a coordinated and credible voice in development policy matters has been a historic accomplishment on the part of Alliance Sud.

I would like to take this opportunity to thank everyone who helped shape and make this story possible. Alliance Sud has initiated a series of policy changes over these past 50 years; it has played a part in expanding and further enhancing development cooperation and has been an unflagging advocate for a Switzerland that practises solidarity.

Alliance Sud too is ready to evolve. We set this in train in 2021 and will accordingly be strengthening our focus on advocacy and hence our impact by that means. This seems imperative in the light of persisting global challenges and injustices, especially where Swiss policies bear some share of the blame. Besides, the business sector continues to wield disproportionate power and influence, a fact that leads not infrequently to policy decisions that are detrimental to people and environment. It must be legitimate in this connection to ask why Federal Councillors are now calling for the business sector to be more politically engaged, while at the same time attempting to reduce civil society's room for manoeuvre.

What is good for the business sector is not automatically good for Switzerland and the world. Good and sustainable policy decisions also need to take the voices of citizens and civil society into account – we have underscored this repeatedly over the past 50 years. We intend to continue to be actively involved and to stand up for global justice through expertise, dialogue and debate.

Global, Opinion

Communications: from means to programme

06.10.2021, International cooperation

It is a topsy-turvy world. The emerging challenges call for a radical worldwide rethink. Development organisations too are being challenged: not just in terms of their programme but also in their corporate communication. By Jörg Arnold, Fairpicture

Communications: from means to programme

Ex First-Lady Melania Trump in Kenya: such VIP visits could foster a paternalistic concept of development.
© Saul Loeb/AFP

SDC Director Patricia Danzi had this to say in marking the 60th anniversary of the organisation: "We must learn how to convey what international cooperation is about today. Today's international cooperation is not what it was 30 years ago. The world has changed and with it, communication. We now share a common language at international level: the 2030 Agenda.”  The anonymous pictures of emaciated children have all but disappeared from the mailings and websites of aid agencies over the past decade. But has this also signalled a change in the manner in which western development organisations talk about the global South?

There are over 100 ZEWO-certified charities in Switzerland committed to making the world more habitable for all. There are also dozens of other non-certified associations. They are all striving to alleviate hardship and lay the groundwork for sustainably overcoming poverty, hunger and injustice. They are well-versed in communicating the content of their work and bringing their donors closer. They strive to create understanding for the plight of people in need, to strengthen the commitment to concrete assistance, thereby enhancing their own effectiveness.

Through their communications they strongly influence public opinion on societies in the global South. Extensive fundraising campaigns convey emotions that convince donors to contribute. Whether in the form of regular reporting in smaller circles or of well-crafted direct marketing initiatives, they help shape the perception of injustice, poverty, misery and violence on the African continent, in Latin America and in Asia by means of imagery that reflects urgency.

Acid test for development organisations

The business of communication represents a challenge for development organisations. It must be repeatedly legitimised vis-a-vis politicians and the general public, at the same time attracting donations and undertaking awareness-building as an essential part of its civil society mission. To properly do justice to all these aims, organisations have invested appreciably in their communication strategies over recent years. Yet they are especially challenged when it comes to their narrative about the global South. That is where they have to pass the veritable acid test of their credibility.

The criticisms confronting development organisations in the West are many and varied. The very media-savvy activists of nowhitesaviours.org from Uganda, for example, have come forward to denounce what they see as the discriminatory representation of people from the African continent in the communications of NGOs. After a major furore, Britain’s Comic Relief had to close down their very successful fundraising campaigns which entailed celebrities appealing for donations while visiting projects in Africa. In the study entitled “Time to Decolonise Aid” published in May 2021, the authors of peacedirect do not mince their words: “Many current practices and attitudes in the aid system mirror and are derived from the colonial era, which most organisations and donors in the Global North are still reluctant to acknowledge. Certain modern-day practices and norms reinforce colonial dynamics and beliefs such as the ‘White saviour’ ideology visible in fundraising and communications imagery used by INGOs.”

Stereotypes undermine development cooperation

Stereotypical communication rooted in colonial ways of thinking – that is a damning charge levelled at the practices of development agencies. It raises critical questions about the fundamental ethical stance of organisations while also noting an inconsistency with the civil society aim of eliminating power imbalances.

With the Manifesto for Responsible Communication on International Cooperation approved in Berne on 10 September 2020, the members and partners of Alliance Sud sent a binding message. In the introduction to the manifesto the authors state self-critically: “People of the global South are often portrayed as objects and recipients of aid or support while, contrastingly, development organizations and their personnel are portrayed as active subjects and experts. (...) This often reproduces stereotypes. Paternalistic images of development convey the idea of developed countries showing underdeveloped countries how to do things properly.”

Capturing and representing entire continents and their people in images of poverty and dependency is discriminatory. It is degrading if the end effect is to lock people into the role of grateful aid recipients. It is high time for development organisations to jettison a fundraising topos carefully cultivated for many years and highly successful. The ever greater significance of communication in our global society requires that development organisations reflect even more deeply on what their own communication is achieving and its potential for helping to bring about global justice.

Communication is a programme

Climate crisis, migration, humanitarian assistance: Communication by development organisations in the information society of the 21st century is more than just corporate communication and fundraising. Its narratives actively help to shape societal change and inspire influential mindsets. It is up to development organisations to ensure that their communication is aligned with the real-life situations, philosophies and aspirations of the people being portrayed. It therefore behoves not just the operational units but also the communications departments of these organisations to embark on a theory of change process, from which to develop a results-based approach to their work on the basis of a self-reflective situation analysis. This is necessary in order to achieve the impact being pursued by the organisation as a whole.

To do justice to the complexity of the problem areas – encompassing those being portrayed as well as the recipients of the communication – these processes must take on board local players with their diversity of viewpoints, know-how and rights. Gone are the days when development agencies could take the liberty of communicating above the heads of the people who are at the centre of their civil society commitment.
 

Jörg Arnold is a sociologist and was head of Fundraising and Marketing at Caritas Switzerland from 2002 to 2018. He is a co-founder of Fairpicture (fairpicture.org).

Global Logo

global

The Alliance Sud magazine analyses and comments on Switzerland's foreign and development policies. "global" is published four times a year (in german and french) and can be subscribed to free of charge.

Opinion

Switzerland – Mozambique, bad governance

06.12.2021, International cooperation

The credit scandal facilitated by Credit Suisse in Mozambique has clearly revealed to that country’s citizens the contradictory nature of Switzerland’s role in reducing poverty and inequality.

Switzerland – Mozambique, bad governance

A woman selling dried fish at the Central market in Maputo, Mozambique.
© Alfredo D'Amato / Panos Pictures

The author, Faizal Ibramugy, is a journalist in Nampula in northern Mozambique and a media operator.

Switzerland has been cooperating with Mozambique since 1979, and as of 2012 – the year when the loans involved in the so-called “hidden debt” (dívidas ocultas" ) were negotiated – the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC) has been focusing on three priority areas: besides economic development and health, also governance. The continued development of a natural resource-endowed country like Mozambique can only take place through good governance and responsible investment. This is why Swiss support in this field is welcome. However, the scandal surrounding the “hidden debt” is now undermining all its endeavours.

For years Mozambicans have been taught how to govern, how to manage public funds, how to avoid illegal and corrupt practices, which could harm the state, and how to operate transparently. This is the good governance that the Swiss have been transmitting to Mozambicans through their various interventions to further the country’s advancement. Never would Mozambicans have imagined that the economic representatives of a country that gives them lessons in the sustainable management of economic resources would make common cause with their corrupt government. Those involved defrauded the State of over 1 billion dollars, even after feasibility studies had shown that the agreed loans were not sound.

Here, the saying “do as I say but not as I do” is a perfect fit. Mozambicans were being taught not to be corrupt, but employees of Credit Suisse have clearly shown that corruption matters more to them than the transparency that is proclaimed in almost all projects and programmes funded with Swiss money.

Debt forgiveness is not enough

Now that Credit Suisse must shoulder some of the blame by paying a financial penalty of 475 million dollars to the USA and the United Kingdom and granting debt forgiveness worth 200 million dollars to Mozambique, most Mozambicans now hope that this is an opportunity to demand full debt forgiveness before the courts.

In my view however, this would be far from sufficient. Official Switzerland – which supports Mozambique’s aspiration toward the decentralised, equitable and transparent management of resources by state institutions – would moreover have to admit that their efforts of more than 40 years have made no impact. Despite major efforts, Mozambique has failed to appropriate this knowledge, just as Credit Suisse bank employees have shown themselves incapable of issuing a loan in full transparency.

A new governance handbook

Today Mozambicans are saddled with a debt that was approved by deception, in a criminal association of bankers and powerbrokers. Mozambique is confronting an unprecedented disaster, the satisfactory management of which requires not just forgiveness, but also a rethinking of the strategy for promoting good governance.

If this financial scandal that has rocked Mozambique is any indication of what the country has learned over the decades from Switzerland about governance and the management of public affairs, all I can only say is that it is worth nothing. What is urgently needed is a new handbook of governance, transparency and integrity, one that teaches Mozambicans that they themselves are at the top of government. Failing this, cooperation between Switzerland and Mozambique, which was being built on solid foundations, will degenerate into a crying shame, on the back of the “hidden debt” affair.

Press release

New members strengthen Alliance Sud

24.01.2022, International cooperation

New members, a new Director and a new Presidency – all signal the dawn of a new era in the 50-year history of Alliance Sud. In the light of growing inequality and a civil society that is coming under ever greater pressure around the world, it is more crucial than ever to have a powerful voice in development policy in Switzerland.

New members strengthen Alliance Sud

“We are very pleased that Solidar Suisse and Terre des hommes are now two new members that will fully support our shared development endeavours”, says Markus Allemann, President of Alliance Sud and Director of Swissaid. “We are thus deepening the coordination between the leading development organizations and strengthening the voice of the Global South in Swiss politics”.

With the merger of HEKS/EPER and Bread for All at the start of the year, the Alliance Sud member-ship now comprises Swissaid, Fastenaktion, Helvetas, Caritas, Heks/Eper, Solidar Suisse and Terre des hommes. The Swiss Red Cross is also an associate member of the Berne-based association.

The new Director Andreas Missbach too will be breaking fresh ground and harnessing his extensive experience in order to forge ahead with the development of the organization: “Alliance Sud is much more than a lobby organization or an interest group”, he says. “We are a centre of excellence for issues of international cooperation and strive to ensure that Switzerland becomes ”world-compatible”. Without an economy that respects ecosystems and protects the climate system, there will be no world in which we can live; without global justice, there will be no world in which we want to live”.

Alliance Sud represents its member organizations in Parliament and vis-a-vis the Federal Administra-tion. At Alliance Sud, media representatives will find competent professionals capable of furnishing well-founded and differentiated information on matters such as sustainable development, international fiscal and financial policies, trade and climate policy, and corporate responsibility. With its magazine “global”, Alliance Sud provides background information and analyses on Swiss foreign and development policy.

 

Further information:
Markus Allemann, President of Alliance Sud and Director of Swissaid, Tel. +41 79 833 15 69
Andreas Missbach, Director Alliance Sud, Tel. +41 31 390 93 30

Opinion

Switzerland's contribution to saving the UN

21.06.2022, International cooperation

The war in Ukraine has compounded a crisis of values that is bound up with the political instrumentalization of the UN. Neutral countries like Switzerland should strive harder for a better world, says El Hadji Gorgui Wade Ndoye.

Switzerland's contribution to saving the UN

El Hadji Gorgui Wade Ndoye is a journalist accredited to the United Nations in Geneva, correspondent for the "Soleil" newspaper from Senegal, and Director of the Pan-African magazine ContinentPremier.com.
© zVg

 

The major crisis now gripping the United Nations is fundamentally an identity crisis. The universal values that brought nations together are now being tested to their limits under the pressure of militaristic thinking that is entirely divorced from the values of peace and human rights. The war in Ukraine makes this clear. On the one hand, there is a country, a permanent member of the Security Council and which, in the middle of the 21st century, attacks another country under the pretext of denazification. On the other hand, there is a western bloc that is outdoing itself at the level of rhetoric, and has committed resolutely to arming the country concerned.

Besides the climate catastrophe announced by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and confirmed in the report of 18 May published by the World Meteorological Organization, and the humanitarian and food crises, which are being managed as best as possible by a financially weak UN, the war in Ukraine has compounded most of all a crisis of values, which is bound up with the political instrumentalization of the world body. The Geneva-based Human Rights Council itself, successor to the Commission of the same name, does not always escape this instrumentalization. Yet, the United Nations was not created in 1945 on the ruins of the League of Nations based on a dualistic, Manichean worldview.

Makane Moïse Mbengue, Professor at the Faculty of Law of the University of Geneva and member of the Institute for International Law, suggests that "the discourse around the values, aims and basic principles of the United Nations should be reframed". In this context, a key role falls to the African continent, which until recently accounted for almost 70 per cent of the volume of United Nations interventions. As the first continent, and not being part of an Eastern or Western bloc, it is yet again witnessing a confrontation that has come about with the rekindling of the Cold War. As the eldest son of the earth, the continent could offer "that little something extra" to the international community. Likewise, historically neutral countries should strive harder for a better world. This also applies to Switzerland, in particular, and all the more so having just become a member of the Security Council – one of the most important of the six organs of the United Nations. As Swiss sociologist Professor Jean Ziegler reminds us: "The UN is the last line of defence before chaos."

What is Switzerland's role

June 2022 is a historic juncture for Switzerland, in that it will cease to be part of the list of 62 countries that have never sat on the Security Council. With the new trust reposed in it by the United Nations General Assembly, the Swiss Confederation, having joined the UN in 2002, could be that breath of fresh air to relations among the 15 Member States, and more particularly, the five permanent members (China, France, the Russian Federation, the United Kingdom and the United States). Despite the sanctions against Russia, in which Switzerland is also participating, Switzerland's credibility and neutrality could still serve to build bridges between nations. The Swiss Confederation, in concert with other countries from the African and Latin American continents, could therefore work towards reframing the discourse in the Security Council, so that it is better aligned with the ideals of the Charter of the United Nations.

Switzerland could act as a mediator in the current war between Russia and Ukraine, being neither a member of NATO nor of the European Union. To that end, it would need to infuse its values of peace and participatory democracy into this powerful body during its two-year membership of the Council. It will be difficult, if not impossible, to abolish the veto power enshrined in the Charter of the United Nations, and accorded to the five permanent members in virtue of their key role in the founding of the organization. However, together with other countries, Switzerland could draw on the resolution adopted by consensus in the General Assembly on 26 April 2022. It provides that the use of a veto would in future automatically trigger a General Assembly meeting, enabling all UN Member States to scrutinize and comment on the veto. The resolution is entitled "Standing mandate for a General Assembly debate when a veto is cast in the Security Council", and was adopted without a vote, in the wake of Russia's use of the veto in the Council the day after it invaded Ukraine, and calls for its unconditional withdrawal from the country. It signals the creation of a new means by which to exert pressure on the countries with a veto to display greater responsibility. UN Member Countries have entrusted the Council with the principal responsibility for preserving world peace and international security and have agreed that when acting on their behalf, the Council must at all times display the greatest possible sense of responsibility for realizing "the goals and principles of the Charter of the United Nations".

Is neutrality compatible with the Security Council?

Switzerland is committed to the ideals enshrined in the Charter of the United Nations. Its presence in the Security Council must therefore reflect its commitment to peace and security in the world and within the world organization. The fundamental aim of Swiss neutrality is comparable to the aspiration of the United Nations inasmuch as the latter constitutes a law-based system designed to "save succeeding generations from the scourge of war". In fact it is evident that countries whose independence and impartiality vis-à-vis a conflict are beyond question, and which have no direct national interests or hidden agenda bound up with the resolution of the conflict, are predestined for the role of honest broker. The seat in the Security Council offers Switzerland new possibilities to contribute to peace, security and an equitable international order. Even if the UN has so far not fulfilled all its missions successfully, it still remains “the last line of defence before chaos”, to paraphrase John Ziegler.

Opinion

The time is ripe for a change

03.10.2022, International cooperation

Latin America has had enough of the inequality, injustice and corruption of right-wing governments that ignore the real needs of their people, writes Guatemalan journalist Mariela Castañón.

The time is ripe for a change
Curfew after protests against a nickel mining project, in October 2021. Police search a man at a checkpoint in El Estor in the northern coastal province of Izabal, Guatemala.
© AP Photo/Moises Castillo

Over recent years, left-wing governments have won elections in countries like Mexico, Bolivia, Peru, Honduras, Chile and Colombia. This reflects people’s unmistakable demand that priority be given to social policy.

There is obvious and palpable disenchantment with right-wing governments, which not only have left nothing behind for their people, but instead have plundered the public coffers to enrich themselves. Although each country has its own reasons for electing a new government, the problems plaguing us are similar. They are poverty, extreme poverty and inequality.

The corona pandemic has further compounded the problems with which we in Latin America have been grappling for decades. The collapse of health and education systems, unemployment, lack of decent housing, and food shortages – all of this makes it clear why left-wing governments are now expected to bring about change.

With uncanny regularity, the political right courts the privileged and corrupt elites, who do nothing to help the poorest in the society, but are more committed to amassing wealth for themselves and safeguarding their own interests and those of their closest cronies.

The challenge now is to bring about changes that are worthy of the name, and to ensure that the words of left-wing government representatives are followed by deeds that benefit the people – rather than by populism, demagoguery and authoritarianism, as we too have experienced it.

Nicaragua is an example of those countries under authoritarian rule where criticism is met with brutal suppression. The Nicaragua of today is no longer a shining example of identification with the Left that it once was. There are now countless people sitting in jail in Nicaragua for having rebelled against the regime of Daniel Ortega and Rosario Murillo; others have been forced into exile. There is simply no limit to the oppression and violence being faced by our Central American brothers and sisters. It fills us with pain to see them suffering in this way. Many other countries have also taken a similar path.

Between misgivings and hope

It is hard to predict what the Latin American Left in general is capable of, for despite the striving for change, politics remains vulnerable to unexpected developments. It is up to us to keep an eye on our elected leaders and to act as committed and responsible citizens.

It is, of course, no simple matter being engaged as a citizen, social activist or journalist in countries where oppression and violence are daily fare and where our human rights and constitutional guarantees are flouted.

In my native country Guatemala, for example, a Central American country with over 17 million inhabitants, fear is our constant companion if we speak out against the corrupt rulers or stand up in defence of the living spaces and rights of indigenous communities.

In March 2022, we learned of “Mining Secrets”, a “Green Blood” project coordinated by the “Forbidden Stories” network in cooperation with 40 journalists from around the world, and which revealed environmental scandals surrounding mining companies. Journalists who reported on popular protests against a local mining company – a subsidiary of the Solway Group, which is domiciled in Switzerland and run by Russian and Estonian nationals – were harassed by the Guatemalan authorities and persons with close links to the company.

A hacker collective calling itself “Red McCaw”, after a native parrot species, passed hundreds of documents to “Forbidden Stories”. The documents obviously originated from the subsidiary of the Solway Group, and reveal the way journalists reporting on the mining company were documented, watched and even followed around by the company’s security services.

It turned out that the company had set aside a budget for drone surveillance of the local people and journalists.

This leaked information paints a picture of impunity and protection of offenders. The abuses committed against the press, the environment and the Guatemalan people have remained without consequence.

“Mining Secrets” further revealed scientific studies and “friendships bought” with “generous” donations by the company. Also coming to light were the strategies used by the mines to drive away and stigmatise families in order to get at the iron and nickel deposits under their houses.

Without a doubt, the environmental crisis and global warming are forcing us to change our lifestyles and put an end to industrial policies that are detrimental to the environment and to the lives of the people they place at risk. In Guatemala, however, it would seem that there is still no awareness of these dangers, and the governments continue to issue licences allowing unregulated mining to continue, which soon or later will take a very heavy toll.

The integrity and life of social activists, engaged citizens and journalists are in constant danger, as public denouncement, activism and truthful and up-to-date reporting uncover the methods being deployed by powerful corporations, which often enough are protected by the very State itself. The consequences are surveillance and threats, and not infrequently, these people pay for their commitment with their lives.

Real change

As children of the Third World, we have the strength to keep fighting for our causes, and will not abandon the hope that someday there will be governments in power that place people at the centre of their social policy.

The shift towards left wing governments reflects the urgency of the situation and the desire to overcome the inequality and injustice we have inherited from right-wing governments notorious for their ineffectiveness and corruption.

It is to be hoped that the left-wing governments will reverse the policies followed by their predecessors, failing which the stage will be set for yet another disappointment for millions of people in the continent.

Latin America needs capable leaders with transparent and legitimate strategies for transforming health, education, food, security and other systems, so that the change can be worthwhile.

Mariela%20Casta%C3%B1%C3%B3n.jpg

© Mariela Castañón

The Guatemalan journalist Mariela Castañón is Professor of Deontology of Communication at the University Rafael Landívar. This summer she was in Switzerland participating in the exchange programme of "En Quête d'Ailleurs (EQDA)".